Skip to content
PizzaHQ

Roman tonda vs New York-style pizza

The fuller page on this is Compare any two styles.

FieldRoman tondaNew York-style pizza
OriginItaly, RomeUnited States, New York City
Formroundround, large format
Thicknessvery thinthin
Rim / edgeThin, flat, no distinct raised rimModerate, slightly raised rim, less pronounced than Neapolitan
Base textureUniformly thin and crisp, audibly crunchyThin, foldable, with a firmer crumb than Neapolitan
CrumbMinimal to no open crumb; dense and cracker-like throughoutModerately open, chewier and less irregular than Neapolitan
Hydration55–62% (typically 58%)60–65% (typically 62%)
Fermentationcold fermentation, prefermentedcold fermentation
ShapingRolled out with a pin to an even, thin roundHand-tossed or hand-stretched to a large, thin round
FlourType 00 flour (commonly used)Bread flour (traditional)
PrefermentBiga (common modern approach)Direct dough method (common modern approach)
Topping loadmoderatemoderate
Bake temperature280–320 °C (typically 300 °C)290–320 °C (typically 300 °C)
Bake time5–8 min (typically 6 min)5–8 min (typically 6.5 min)
OvenCommercial deck oven, Domestic fan (convection) oven, Gas-fired pizza ovenCommercial deck oven, Domestic fan (convection) oven, Gas-fired pizza oven
Flavourclean, savourysavoury, rich
Texturecrisp, brittle, crunchychewy, foldable, crisp
Difficultyintermediateintermediate
Domestic suitabilitygoodgood
ServingServed whole, cut into wedges with a wheel cutterSold by the slice or whole pie, folded lengthwise to eat ('the New York fold')

Key similarities

  • Topping load
  • Oven
  • Difficulty
  • Domestic suitability

Key differences

  • Origin
  • Form
  • Thickness
  • Rim / edge
  • Base texture
  • Crumb
  • Hydration
  • Fermentation
  • Shaping
  • Flour
  • Preferment
  • Bake temperature
  • Bake time
  • Flavour
  • Texture
  • Serving